Whither continuity of thought?

India’s selectors are more inconsistent than the youths they so casually pick and drop.

Remember Parwinder Awana?

Anybody who has ever been a success at anything will tell you this: it helps to have a goal, and it helps to have a plan to reach that goal. In academics, business, sport, or any walk of life, setting goals is the first step towards success. But a shifting goalpost only produces scattershot results.

This is why the Australian teams over the years have been so tough to beat. They clearly identify what they want to win, they identify the players who will help them win, and they don’t stop. After 1999, they planned on winning the 2003 World Cup, and then again in 2007. Even with a depleted side in 2011, they made the quarterfinals. And now, even with the retirements of their great players, it’s still tough to beat them as West Indies found out over the course of five ODIs.

Despite the passage of generations — from Border to Taylor to Waugh and Ponting to Clarke — Australia’s cricketing ideology has been unwavering. In every era they have relentlessly pursued the same goal: of winning when it matters. And for this, they will be one of the best prepared teams when they host the 2015 World Cup.

Jaffer: raw deal?In Indian cricket, such planning and strategising has been largely absent — a reason why they win a World Cup one moment and then get whitewashed the next. Their teams are being built on a series-by-series basis. Their superstars are handled with caution, and young players are being picked and dropped in a manner that often makes no sense.

Which brings us to the Test teams for the home Tests against England and Australia. It’s unclear if a long-term plan has been guiding the selectors’ hands while making their picks.

# Let’s start with the strange practice of punishment exclusions. Virender Sehwag returns to national duty after being dropped from the limited overs squad that played England recently. There’s this strange tendency in Indian cricket to pick and drop players for reasons other than performance. Sehwag was ostensibly dropped due to his wretched form. So naturally, his return to the team must be based on a redeeming performance. But that’s not the case. Sehwag hasn’t played a proper game in over a month. It’s unclear what prompted his return. Was it just the selectors’ way of telling him to behave?

# Meanwhile, Sehwag’s opening partner of nearly five years, Gautam Gambhir has got what was coming to him. He has been replaced by Shikhar Dhawan. Now, the trouble is that the Indian squad already had two openers in Murali Vijay and Ajinkya Rahane. If you still had to bring in an extra opener, perhaps the in-form Wasim Jaffer with nearly a thousand runs in the season may have been a better choice. But what India need more is a good No. 6 batsman because they have left out Yuvraj Singh and Suresh Raina.

# So now we have a strange situation where an opening batsman (Rahane) is competing for the No. 6 spot with Ravindra Jadeja (neither a specialist batsman nor a specialist bowler). Apples for oranges? Meanwhile, Subramaniam Badrinath, who’d been named VVS Laxman’s replacement at No. 6, has been forgotten already. Where’s the continuity of thought?

# Let’s dwell on Jaffer now. He will be 35 this month. He has been among the top scorers in Indian domestic cricket season after season, and probably deserved a chance for the simple reason that India needed a break from the two walking wickets that have been Sehwag and Gambhir. If Jaffer’s age got in his way, how would the selectors justify holding on to the man who will be 40 next month and is far from his best form? Another case of inconsistency of thought? Also, will Sachin Tendulkar be around when India tour South Africa in December? Big question mark.

Will the Harbhajan gamble work?# Before you jump to say “past records”, let’s examine Harbhajan Singh’s case. His 90 wickets in 16 Tests against Australia are largely the result of his good work in 2001 and 2004. In the last three series against his favourite opponent (and over a large part of the last seven-odd years) Harbhajan has been a shadow of his former self. He was dropped and expected to regain his form in domestic cricket — something he still hasn’t done — and yet he has made two comebacks to the Test squad. There's no evidence that his famous turn and bounce are back. And by banking on his tattered reputation, India are asking for trouble in a key series.

# Then there’s the second line of Indian spinners. Amit Mishra made a brief appearance in the ODI squad in December, didn’t play and got dropped. Piyush Chawla played the Nagpur Test, took 4-69 and got dropped. And hey — remember Rahul Sharma, who our selectors said was the next best thing since Kumble?

# The point here is that players need to be picked because they’re the best in the country. Period. Unfortunately, that hasn’t been the case especially with a large number of India’s pacers. Praveen Kumar. Munaf Patel. Abhimanyu Mithun. RP Singh. Sudeep Tyagi. Remember Jaydev Unadkat? What about Parwinder Awana who was said to be the next big prospect and then dropped without getting a game? Let’s hope this isn’t the fate awaiting young Bhuvaneshwar Kumar.

# In their attempt to balance youth with experience, Sandeep Patil’s selection committee has left out Yuvraj, Raina and Gambhir. For a change, it will be nice to see these three work hard to return to the squad instead of being brought back based on past achievements.

# Parting shot — and this is for you, dear readers — man-for-man, is this Indian squad better than Australia’s? Could India have picked a better team? Fire away with the comments, don't hold them back.

Matches

MORE TOP STORIES TODAY

Pietersen may play against Hyderabad

Pietersen may play against Hyderabad

As much as Pietersen's availability is a boost, the loss of a potent death bowler might sting Delhi badly. More »

Bangalore lose nerve, lose game

Bangalore lose nerve, lose game

IPL 7, GAME 11—Vinay's over, Lynn's catch turns last-over finish in KKR's favour. More »

Struggling Mumbai need batting fuel

Struggling Mumbai need batting fuel

Mumbai have explosive hitters down the order in the form of Corey Anderson and Kieron Pollard, but the lack of contributions from them has compounded their… More »

Boycotting IPL will not save cricket

Boycotting IPL will not save cricket

Boycotting the IPL as a means of protest against the grime in the game may not yield the desired results. More »

Srinivasan's ICC presence to be challenged

Srinivasan's ICC presence to be challenged

Srinivasan, who has been replaced by the court as board president, was named the BCCI's representative to the ICC last September. However, that position… More »

Atapattu tipped to coach Sri Lanka in England

Atapattu tipped to coach Sri Lanka in England

Sri Lanka's chief selector Sanath Jayasuriya issued the strongest indication yet that Marvan Atapattu would be appointed coach for the tour of Ireland… More »

Couldn't turn down ECB offer: Farbrace

Couldn't turn down ECB offer: Farbrace

England's new assistant coach Paul Farbrace admitted that it was impossible turn down the job even though he will have mixed feelings when he faces… More »

Cleaning up the game starts with fans

Cleaning up the game starts with fans

... because, as recent events reveal, the BCCI has little intention of doing it. More »

'BCCI should have picked panel with care'

'BCCI should have picked panel with care'

Dalmiya said that it was the first time that the BCCI had been faced with a situation where the apex court had hauled up the Board and it should have acted… More »

Jadeja spins out Rajasthan in close chase

Jadeja spins out Rajasthan in close chase

IPL 7, GAME 10—Chennai beat Rajasthan by 7 runs after last-over scare. More »

Is Srini group delaying BCCI meeting?

Is Srini group delaying BCCI meeting?

The group opposed to Srinivasan alleged that since BCCI secretary Sanjay Patel belongs to the president’s group, he was intentionally delaying the SGM… More »

Vithanage, Priyanjan get T20 call-ups

Vithanage, Priyanjan get T20 call-ups

Herath has been rested, while the team will be without the veteran pair of Mahela Jayawardene and Kumar Sangakkara, who retired from T20 internationals… More »

'Gambhir will strike form soon'

'Gambhir will strike form soon'

Gautam made an eight-ball duck in the opening game against Mumbai and in the second game against Delhi, he lasted only half those balls. More »

SL in 'difficult place' after Farbrace exit

SL in 'difficult place' after Farbrace exit

Sri Lanka depart for assignments in Ireland and England in two weeks, and Sanath Jayasuriya suggested Marvan Atapattu would be interim head coach for those… More »

Chandimal axed as T20 captain

Chandimal axed as T20 captain

Sri Lanka's cricket selectors on Wednesday sacked Dinesh Chandimal as Twenty20 captain and replaced him with Lasith Malinga, while Angelo Mathews was… More »

Farbrace is England's assistant coach

Farbrace is England's assistant coach

The ECB continued the restructuring of the England coaching set-up on Wednesday by announcing the appointment of Paul Farbrace as assistant coach. More »

SC asks Mudgal committee to continue

SC asks Mudgal committee to continue

Mukul Mudgal has communicated to the court his willingness to take up the investigation and has been asked to specify the terms and modalities on April… More »

Sri Lanka players resolve pay dispute

Sri Lanka players resolve pay dispute

The pay dispute between Sri Lanka Cricket and its 13 contracted players ended on Wednesday when the latter agreed to accept 10 percent of the participation… More »

Hope to be fit for next game - Pietersen

Hope to be fit for next game - Pietersen

With two heavy defeats at the hands of Bangalore and Chennai, Daredevils currently languish near the bottom of the table. More »

'SC decision could hurt BCCI's status'

'SC decision could hurt BCCI's status'

The Supreme Court prefers that the Justice Mudgal panel further investigate the IPL corruption scandal. More »

Mudgal panel drops bombshell in court

Mudgal panel drops bombshell in court

The Mukul Mudgal probe committee dropped a bombshell in the Supreme Court on Tuesday by making a sensational claim that it was forced to stop audio recording… More »

Perfect Punjab trounce Hyderabad

Perfect Punjab trounce Hyderabad

IPL7, GAME 9—Maxwell (95, 43b), Balaji (4-13) set up 72-run win. More »

Have the ECB played an unfair game?

Have the ECB played an unfair game?

Money talks, but it is in light of this ICC shakeup that the ECB's act of soliciting of another team's coach deteriorates from free-market aggression to… More »

Farbrace quits for England post

Farbrace quits for England post

He will assist Peter Moores who was unveiled as the new England coach on Saturday. More »