Vital footage missing from Park Street rape case disc

Calcutta, Jan. 12: A vital piece of evidence in the Park Street rape case cannot be found, probably because initial police complacency and a mix-up of identities led to delay in preserving original footage.

The central forensic science laboratory at Park Circus, which was entrusted with retrieving the relevant CCTV footage in which the suspects and the victim were reportedly last seen together, could not find it in the four hard discs taken by the police.

Only one disc was relevant because it covered the parking lot of the star hotel on Park Street that they left around 2.40am on February 6, 2012. But the disc apparently had no video evidence of what happened there until 6am.

"CCTV cameras near the hotel's parking lot had captured the victim and the accused around the time they left the premises. Four CCTVs (of the hotel) were taken and sent to the forensic lab for examination. But the forensic report says the relevant part was not there. Despite using a special software, the forensic experts could not retrieve it," said a detective department officer.

It was assumed till now that the police had video evidence of the suspects leaving the hotel with the victim in their car in which the alleged gang rape took place. In a case ' such as this one ' where there is no witness or a conclusive medical report to prove sexual assault, proof of being "last seen together" just before the crime could have been "clinching evidence when placed along with the victim's testimony", a police source said.

An officer who probed the case insisted that the absence of footage was not a body blow. The victim's statement and the identification of the suspects by her are far more important, he added to reinforce his assertion that the police still have a strong case.

But officers not connected with the case said that such confidence could not be an excuse for losing real-time footage.

Police sources are now saying that the relevant portion probably got "overwritten" (taped over on a subsequent day). The purported sequence of events (see chart) suggests that the police had a chance to take the disc three days from the incident but did so only after nine days.

An officer initially copied the footage on a pen drive ' which is still intact but doubts have been raised if the secondary recording will hold up before legal scrutiny. The seizure list presented by the police in court does not mention the pen-drive footage. It refers to the hard discs.

The investigation had initially appeared to be flagging for two reasons. One, the suspects identified by the victim had watertight alibis. Two, told of the initial confusion but before investigations were complete, the chief minister described it as a sajano ghatana (fabricated case).

Sections of the police appeared to suggest that the mistaken identification had led to the loss of valuable time and, as a consequence, the footage.

But others familiar with rape investigations have said trauma often confuses victims and a clear picture emerges only through sensitive and patient questioning. In the immediate aftermath of a complaint, the onus lies on the investigators to gather as much material evidence as early as possible and ensure that the proof is left untouched.

The police had a chance to take possession of the original disc a day after the victim filed the complaint. An officer had asked the hotel to show the CCTV footage from the night of February 5 and copied it on a pen drive.

"The CCTVs installed in that hotel are programmed to store footage for up to four days. Recording of the fifth day will overwrite the footage of the first day," another officer said.

For some reason, the police did not take the disc immediately but apparently asked the hotel to stop recording further so that the old recordings were not lost. The Telegraph was unable to corroborate the version with the hotel because of the late hour at which the information from multiple sources was gathered.

According to the police, recording was resumed on February 14 after two youths were picked up and the victim "identified" them. If what the police are saying is true, the recording was resumed on the probable assumption that the case had been cracked.

But why footage that can be evidence was not kept in police custody and why it was eventually taped over ' if at all such "overwriting" took place ' are not clear.

The next day, the police realised their mistake but even then the disc was not taken.

"A day later, after it emerged that one of the men the lady was referring to had been living in Canada for several months, the police realised that it was a case of mistaken identity and the real culprits were still at large. The police asked the hotel to again stop recording on February 15. But by then, the recording had been on for a few hours," said an officer.

The hard disc was taken only on the evening of February 15.

Asked why the hard discs were not seized the day the footage was copied on the pen drive, an officer attached with the probe replied with a question: "How could we seize something before being confirmed that it might hold evidence?"

The police claimed that initially when the victim was shown the footage from the pen drive, she had not been able to identify herself. The hard disc was seized on the evening of February 15, only after she identified herself from a jacket.

According to forensic experts, the "relevant data" had either been overwritten or has "got scattered" ' a technical term that means a particular portion of the video has not been stored where it should have been ' in the hard disc and could not be retrieved.

The forensic report was submitted several months after the police submitted the chargesheet. As the evidence from the hard discs was not ready when the chargesheet was submitted in May, 2012, the police submitted six still photographs derived from the pen-drive images showing the victim and the accused.

However, with the lab reporting loss of original hard disc footage, the question is if a court will accept the pen drive as corroborative evidence.

Legal experts said since the inception of the Information Technology Act in 2000, several amendments have been made in the Indian Evidence Act and the Criminal Procedure Code. "Unlike earlier, when courts did not take cognisance of electronic evidence like CCTV footage and mobile clippings, the scenario has changed after the inception of the IT Act. Courts do consider electronic evidence as secondary evidence now," said a senior Calcutta High Court lawyer.

A victim's version, medical reports and eyewitness accounts are considered primary evidence.

The lawyer expressed doubts whether the pen drive would be acceptable as evidence before the court as it was "not formally seized" by the police.

A section of the police said the primary evidence was strong enough.

"In this case, the victim's statement and the test identification parade are most important. The statement of the hotel staff and the bouncers who saw her leave with the accused will also count," said an officer of the women's grievance cell that investigated the case.

The victim's medical reports are said to have suggested only "physical assault" and indicated nothing definite about a sexual attack. The police also have with them a ticket of NRS Hospital's outpatient department where she had gone for medical examination.

"Though the NRS report doesn't claim that the woman was sexually assaulted, the outpatient department ticket says she was there to get treated for a sexual assault. It could always have been a lapse on the part of the doctor concerned that he forgot or dropped the part that indicated sexual assault," said a police officer.

The police have also submitted to court an earring ' one from a pair ' that was found from the Honda City in which the woman was allegedly raped.

A chemical report obtained from the state forensic laboratory has not been of much help to the police.

Matches

MORE TOP STORIES TODAY

Duminy steals first win for Delhi

Duminy steals first win for Delhi

Furious fifties by Duminy and Dinesh Karthik end a long losing streak for the Daredevils. More »

AB, Parthiv seal Bangalore's second win

AB, Parthiv seal Bangalore's second win

Royal Challengers overcame a stutter to cruise to the small target they were set by Mumbai Indians. More »

Glenn Maxwell carves his parallel universe

Glenn Maxwell carves his parallel universe

Glenn Maxwell seems to project an icy disdain when at the crease. Match situations rarely faze him and the bubble in which he plays excludes everyone … More »

Srinivasan can attend BCCI meeting

Srinivasan can attend BCCI meeting

His status as president of TNCA makes him eligible to attend the Working Committee meeting on Sunday. More »

No way back for Pietersen: ECB

No way back for Pietersen: ECB

Kevin Pietersen's hopes of reviving his international career appeared to end Saturday when ECB managing director Paul Downton said there was 'no way back'… More »

[REWIND] The world record that nearly wasn't

[REWIND] The world record that nearly wasn't

Twenty years ago this week, Brian Lara became Test cricket's highest scorer, but he almost didn't make it. More »

Moores gets second stint as England coach

Moores gets second stint as England coach

In a two-year spell from 2007 to 2009, the 51-year-old Moores led England in seven Test series. More »

Bangladesh senior players to see shrink

Bangladesh senior players to see shrink

Bangladesh's senior players will have three sessions with a psychological skill development coach later this month More »

BCCI is not anybody’s property — Dalmiya

BCCI is not anybody’s property — Dalmiya

Dalmiya feels that Srinivasan’s ‘power hungry’ attitude isn’t helping matters. More »

KP ridicules idea of day-night Tests

KP ridicules idea of day-night Tests

Kevin Pietersen has ridiculed the idea of day-night Test cricket, saying the game would be so different to proper Test cricket that we will need a whole… More »

Rajasthan edge low-scoring thriller

Rajasthan edge low-scoring thriller

The bowlers restricted Hyderabad to 133 for 6 before Rahane and Binny took Rajasthan over the line. More »

Tough for bowlers: Saeed Ajmal

Tough for bowlers: Saeed Ajmal

The 36-year-old believes the T20 format and rule changes in 50-over matches have made a real difference. More »

Maxwell blitz takes Punjab home

Maxwell blitz takes Punjab home

The Kings XI batsman blasted a 43-ball 95 to help his team pull off a massive chase against Chennai Super Kings. More »

BCCI members want independent probe

BCCI members want independent probe

The board members are realising after the Supreme Court's observations that something has to be done — IS Bindra More »

'BCCI lacks leaders to take on Srini'

'BCCI lacks leaders to take on Srini'

Two former BCCI presidents, Shashank Manohar and Jagmohan Dalmiya, have reacted strongly to the news of the BCCI calling an emergent meeting on Sunday… More »

Delhi look for first points against confident Kolkata

Delhi look for first points against confident Kolkata

Preview — The threat of Sunil Narine looms large again. More »

Bangalore vs Mumbai: A battle of the big-hitters

Bangalore vs Mumbai: A battle of the big-hitters

Preview — Given the firepower in both line-ups, Dubai crowd may see another high-scorer More »

Yuvraj tees off to Sharjah's delight

Yuvraj tees off to Sharjah's delight

Yuvraj Singh was hardly convincing to begin with against Delhi, but a big dose of crowd support and a helping of poor bowling meant he had the opportunity… More »

Stressed Trott stands down again

Stressed Trott stands down again

The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) on Friday confirmed that batsman Jonathan Trott is to take another break from all cricket with immediate eff… More »

PCB starts another coach hunt

PCB starts another coach hunt

The PCB has decided to not extend the contracts of head coach Moin Khan, fielding coach Shoaib Mohammad and batting consultant Zaheer Abbas, and has invited… More »

Fiery star Stokes bids to curb his temper

Fiery star Stokes bids to curb his temper

England all-rounder Ben Stokes admits he must keep his anger under control if he is to end his international exile. More »

Bangalore's arsenal blazes to victory

Bangalore's arsenal blazes to victory

Yuvraj Singh was back to his best in his first match for Royal Challengers Bangalore. More »

Pakistan cricketers face probe

Pakistan cricketers face probe

Pakistani cricket authorities have launched an investigation after a number of current international stars played in exhibition matches in the United States… More »

BCCI to meet before next court hearing

BCCI to meet before next court hearing

The BCCI will hold an emergent working committee meeting on April 20 to discuss the future course of action with regard to the Supreme Court hearing concerning… More »