O captain, my captain...

India, April 21 -- Good captaincy is like pornography; it's difficult to define but you know it when you see it. When a captain signals from the opening delivery, he's trying to win the Test match, there's an urgency on the field and an expectation in the stands. Conversely, when a captain pushes fielders back allowing the batsman a single so the fielding side can attack a tail-ender, there's no logic to the ploy.

Once a captain basically stops trying to dismiss a batsman, the fans might as well adjourn to the bar because the contest is then like Monty Python's dead parrot - it has ceased to be.

These are two extreme examples and most international captaincy falls somewhere in between those parameters. Nevertheless captaincy, like the game, is constantly evolving and what was once deemed practical, is often declared out of date.

Changing times

Mahendra Singh Dhoni made a reference to the changing nature of field placements following the recent whitewash against Australia. While his point is taken about requiring alternative field placings in an era of aggressive batsmen, armed with meatier weapons and enjoying shorter boundaries, there's one axiom a skipper should never ignore; try to do what the batsman would like least.

This adage applies equally to field placements and bowling changes. The most difficult aspect of captaincy is when the opposition begins to assert their authority. The fielding captain then has to warily traverse the high wire and balance the saving of runs with letting the batsmen know their wicket is still under threat.

In these periods of play a match can quickly slip away or hopes may be revived, depending on the awareness and boldness of the fielding captain. A bold captain who holds his nerve in this situation can make believers out of his team-mates and then nothing appears impossible.

Too many cooks...

However, on field is only part of the job. The leadership aspect of captaincy is critical and this is where modern trends may be hampering captains and not allowing them to do the job properly.

When I was interviewed for the Argus report in 2011, I said in part; "I don't think the current system allows you to captain Australia properly."

Why not was the harrumphed response. "Because there are too many people to tell to get stuffed," I replied. As captain, I only needed to tell the team manager to keep his nose out of the cricket side of the business.

Now, there's up to a dozen coaches, fitness and medical guys and even a high performance manager, who all need to be reminded of their place. All these people are looking to justify their existence. Instead of Michael Clarke, along with a few of his trusted senior players mapping out the plan for each day's play, the skipper now receives more input than the US President - and generally from people who are not qualified to captain a primary school cricket team.

Grossly unfair

It's a ridiculous burden to place on any captain and it inhibits good leadership. Apart from a bit of preparatory work in consultation with the players, the captaincy is best left to the skipper on the field.

If the captain isn't doing the job properly, the solution is not to provide him with more advisors but to sack him and find someone who is up to the task.

If there's a dearth of leadership candidates then the system is failing and improvements are needed but replacing coaches will not solve the problem.

Captaincy by committee doesn't work. One of the craziest suggestions I ever heard was the idea of wiring up captain Hansie Cronje so he could hear off-field coach Bob Woolmer. A captain has to be confident of his decisions and the last thing he needs is to be constantly second guessed or bombarded with ideas. If a captain needs an earpiece then find him a job as a security guard.

Learning on the job

The best way to improve as a captain is by doing the job. A junior captain can also learn from watching renowned skippers but he won't improve if he's surrounded by off-field advisors in the development stage.

That system becomes self-fulfilling when he's later appointed at the international level where he has to be supported by even more advisors.

Developing a few strong leaders is just as important as producing competitive young cricketers. That should be the aim of every international administration and their production lines need to reflect those aims.

Published by HT Syndication with permission from Hindustan Times.

Matches

MORE TOP STORIES TODAY

Indian seam scuttles England

Indian seam scuttles England

1st TEST, 3rd DAY: Bhuvneshwar and Ishant combine for seven; England trail by 105, one wicket remaining. More »

Ishant's rewards for the dirty work

Ishant's rewards for the dirty work

Ishant Sharma is an odd sort of an 'attack leader', averaging over 37 in Test cricket and not given the new ball. More »

[SCHEDULE]  India's bilateral matches

[SCHEDULE] India's bilateral matches

India's bilateral matches from Dec 2014 to Jan 2023. More »

LIVE: Sri Lanka vs South Africa, 3rd ODI

LIVE: Sri Lanka vs South Africa, 3rd ODI

LIVE: Sri Lanka vs South Africa, 3rd ODI More »

Katich ends career with T20 retirement

Katich ends career with T20 retirement

Simon Katich has announced his retirement from T20s, thus ending his career as a player in all forms of the game. More »

Change of attitude aids remarkable stand

Change of attitude aids remarkable stand

India's recent track of record of lower-order runs is poor, but they began correcting that with a mammoth 10th wicket stand which showed the application… More »

[NOSTALGIA] Life with David Gower

[NOSTALGIA] Life with David Gower

David Gower was on the verge of being dropped for good at The Oval in 1990 before he scored a charismatic 157 against India. More »

The joy of one, the pain of another

The joy of one, the pain of another

The No. 11 of India's order did something the No. 1 of England's order can only dream of at the moment: score a Test fifty. More »

Mohammad Kaif set for Andra move

Mohammad Kaif set for Andra move

Mohammad Kaif, the former India batsman, is set to leave Uttar Pradesh and join Andhra for the upcoming domestic season. More »

[PREVIEW] SL vs SA, 3rd ODI

[PREVIEW] SL vs SA, 3rd ODI

A quicker surface is expected in Hambantota as South Africa chase a series win against a team in form. More »

Gavaskar writes to SC about BCCI position

Gavaskar writes to SC about BCCI position

The former captain, who was put in-charge of BCCI for the duration of this year's IPL, has sought clarification about his current role. More »

Bhuvneshwar, Shami in record-breaking stand

Bhuvneshwar, Shami in record-breaking stand

Indian batsmen, including the lower order, apply themselves to bat long periods collecting records along the way. More »

Cook's dismissal betrays frazzled mind

Cook's dismissal betrays frazzled mind

Some may say that the England captain's dismissal was unlucky, but it was the latest example of the demons he is battling as the form slump grows long… More »

India's opening conundrum

In the last three-and-half-years, India's opening combinations have averaged 18 per partnership overseas, with only one 50-plus stand in 35 attempts More »

Bracewell replaces Milne in NZ A squad

Bracewell replaces Milne in NZ A squad

Fast bowler Doug Bracewell has been called up to the New Zealand A squad for the tour of England as a replacement for the injured Adam Milne. More »

Zimbabwe set for major changes

Zimbabwe set for major changes

ZC's cricket committee has suggested appointing a director of cricket to oversee all training programs and splitting the captaincy across formats More »

Duminy keen to dispel spin demons

Duminy keen to dispel spin demons

JP Duminy wants to use the final ODI to prove the team can handle spin More »

India gets a tail-end boost

India gets a tail-end boost

Although they lost four quick wickets after lunch, India rode a last-wicket 111-run partnership to safety. More »

Millionaire Vijay meets the coal-miner

Millionaire Vijay meets the coal-miner

The opener needed a bit of luck. And he made it count at Trent Bridge. More »

Sethi returned as PCB chief

Sethi returned as PCB chief

Yesterday, he had been removed by the apex court. More »

Highlights: England vs India, 1st Test

All the moments that mattered during the series opener. [Scores] More »

How to get through five Tests in 42 days

How to get through five Tests in 42 days

England and India must trade players across teams and also consider part-time positions. More »

In Larwood country

In Larwood country

This correspondent heads to Nuncargate to find out more about one of England's most fearsome fast bowlers. More »

Groundsman apologises for 'Indian' pitch

Groundsman apologises for 'Indian' pitch

Nottinghamshire head groundsman Steve Birks said things hadn't gone to plan after appearing to produce a pitch ideally suited for India, rather than… More »