Nandy gets relief with a rap

New Delhi, Feb. 1: The Supreme Court today stayed Ashis Nandy's arrest but minced no words in expressing displeasure at his purported remarks about Dalits, tribals and OBCs, saying he has "no licence to make such comments".

"Tell your client he doesn't have the licence to make such comments," a three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice of India Altamas Kabir told Nandy's lawyer.

Every individual has the right to express an idea but not by disturbing public interest and tranquillity, the judges said, after Nandy's lawyer alleged, without elaborating, that the comments were being "distorted" and that a "hysteria" was being generated.

"Who is saying that? Please don't say such things. Or is it that you are under the instructions of your client," the bench said.

Nandy had named the "OBCs, the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes" as the most corrupt sections.

The court sought the responses of the Centre and the Rajasthan, Chhattisgarh, Maharashtra and Bihar governments to Nandy's petition seeking quashing of multiple FIRs in the states for his controversial remarks on January 26 at the Jaipur Literary Festival.

Nandy drew the court's ire after his senior counsel, Aman Lekhi, wanted to know if the "law can penalise an idea". Justice Kabir retorted: "Yes, why not? When the idea is not in public interest."

Lekhi said a person cannot be faulted because he or she conveys a certain idea. Justice Kabir said: "Yes, an idea can be punished. It is not just a question of the idea. It is the way in which the idea is conveyed."

At this stage, a lawyer claiming to represent Dalits sought permission to move a plea opposing Nandy's plea to quash the FIRs. The bench then pointed to the lawyer and said: "This man says he is hurt. Each person has his idea. But it should not disturb others. In the context of ideas you can't go on making such remarks. When statements are being made, it has to be made in a responsible manner."

Lekhi argued the filing of multiple FIRs in a case was contrary to law. The bench disagreed: "Why not many FIRs? Because people at different places are affected."

Nandy has denied intentional insult or intimidation with intent to humiliate SCs and STs and, as such, argued that he had not violated the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, and Section 506 of the IPC (criminal intimidation). The FIRs have been filed under these sections.

Nandy urged the court to lay down proper guidelines to prevent violation of freedom of speech and expression guaranteed under Article 19 of the Constitution. He also sought steps to stop what he called the misuse of the SC/ST Act saying it amounted to violation of fundamental rights.

Nandy's petition pointed to "recurring instances of condemnation of freedom of speech and expression as hate speech which results in academicians, intellectuals and scholars being ostracised".

"(This) requires this hon'ble court to provide guidelines as to what alone is proscribed to ensure the freedom to communicate… the soul of right to freedom of expression… is not hindered or muzzled by abuse of political position or misuse of administrative power."

On the alleged misuse of the SC/ST Act, Nandy's plea claimed the government itself has acknowledged it. "It is an admitted fact that Section 3(1)(x) of SC/ST Act is being misused, as noted by ministry of social Justice and empowerment in its press release dated 11.08.2011. The misuse requires various guidelines to be framed."

Nandy said because of the "surcharged environment and rabid statements by important political personalities", his physical safety was at stake.

Matches

MORE TOP STORIES TODAY

On Now: Rajasthan Royals vs Kings XI Punjab

On Now: Rajasthan Royals vs Kings XI Punjab

GAME 7, SHARJAH—Fifties from Watson, Samson power Rajasthan to a big score. More »

Royal test for Kings

Royal test for Kings

Preview — Clash of philosophies between Australia-centric teams More »

Have nothing to prove to anybody — Sehwag

Have nothing to prove to anybody — Sehwag

The Nawab of Najafgarh says a good run in IPL could help his chances of a comeback on India's tour to England in June. More »

Shastri in proposed IPL probe panel

Shastri in proposed IPL probe panel

Some members stressed on the need for proposing names with an "impeccable record and clean image". More »

Duminy steals first win for Delhi

Duminy steals first win for Delhi

Furious fifties by Duminy and Dinesh Karthik end a long losing streak for the Daredevils. More »

Five things England must do to bounce back

Five things England must do to bounce back

England have appointed a new head coach in Peter Moores. More »

AB, Parthiv seal Bangalore's second win

AB, Parthiv seal Bangalore's second win

Royal Challengers overcame a stutter to cruise to the small target they were set by Mumbai Indians. More »

‘Felt like helpless minority’

‘Felt like helpless minority’

Former BCCI treasurer Ajay Shirke says emotions got the better of Srinivasan and he tried to oversimplify things by calling Meiyappan an “enthusiast.” More »

No way back for Pietersen: ECB

No way back for Pietersen: ECB

Kevin Pietersen's hopes of reviving his international career appeared to end Saturday when ECB managing director Paul Downton said there was 'no way back'… More »

Srinivasan can attend BCCI meeting

Srinivasan can attend BCCI meeting

His status as president of TNCA makes him eligible to attend the Working Committee meeting on Sunday. More »

Maxwell carves his parallel universe

Maxwell carves his parallel universe

Glenn Maxwell seems to project an icy disdain when at the crease. Match situations rarely faze him and the bubble in which he plays excludes everyone … More »

The world record that nearly wasn't

The world record that nearly wasn't

Twenty years ago this week, Brian Lara became Test cricket's highest scorer, but he almost didn't make it. More »

Moores gets second stint as coach

Moores gets second stint as coach

In a two-year spell from 2007 to 2009, the 51-year-old Moores led England in seven Test series. More »

Bangladesh senior players to see shrink

Bangladesh senior players to see shrink

Bangladesh's senior players will have three sessions with a psychological skill development coach later this month More »

BCCI is not anybody’s property — Dalmiya

BCCI is not anybody’s property — Dalmiya

Dalmiya feels that Srinivasan’s ‘power hungry’ attitude isn’t helping matters. More »

Tough for bowlers: Saeed Ajmal

Tough for bowlers: Saeed Ajmal

The 36-year-old believes the T20 format and rule changes in 50-over matches have made a real difference. More »

KP ridicules idea of day-night Tests

KP ridicules idea of day-night Tests

Kevin Pietersen has ridiculed the idea of day-night Test cricket, saying the game would be so different to proper Test cricket that we will need a whole… More »

Rajasthan edge low-scoring thriller

Rajasthan edge low-scoring thriller

The bowlers restricted Hyderabad to 133 for 6 before Rahane and Binny took Rajasthan over the line. More »

Maxwell blitz takes Punjab home

Maxwell blitz takes Punjab home

The Kings XI batsman blasted a 43-ball 95 to help his team pull off a massive chase against Chennai Super Kings. More »

BCCI members want independent probe

BCCI members want independent probe

The board members are realising after the Supreme Court's observations that something has to be done — IS Bindra More »

'BCCI lacks leaders to take on Srini'

'BCCI lacks leaders to take on Srini'

Two former BCCI presidents, Shashank Manohar and Jagmohan Dalmiya, have reacted strongly to the news of the BCCI calling an emergent meeting on Sunday… More »

Delhi look for first points against confident Kolkata

Delhi look for first points against confident Kolkata

Preview — The threat of Sunil Narine looms large again. More »

Bangalore vs Mumbai: A battle of the big-hitters

Bangalore vs Mumbai: A battle of the big-hitters

Preview — Given the firepower in both line-ups, Dubai crowd may see another high-scorer More »

Yuvraj tees off to Sharjah's delight

Yuvraj tees off to Sharjah's delight

Yuvraj Singh was hardly convincing to begin with against Delhi, but a big dose of crowd support and a helping of poor bowling meant he had the opportunity… More »