Don’t Use And Throw Your Legends

Yahoo cricket editorial blogs
The retrograde move to recall Dravid can only end badly for him.

The retrograde move to recall Dravid can only end badly for him.

India’s ODI squad for England is along expected lines. Sachin Tendulkar was expected to play this important series. Harbhajan Singh has been rested due to injury or dropped due to excruciatingly bad form, depending on whose word you take. Sreesanth has been used and thrown away as the team has seen fit. And there’s still no sign of Ashish Nehra despite him submitting a fitness certificate.

But the one selection we didn't see coming was Rahul Dravid. "Rested", incidentally, was the word used to describe his absence from the ODI team in 2007, when he was actually dropped.

Considering Dravid's recent good run in Test cricket, it's easy to understand why he has been recalled. In making three hundreds in trying conditions, he brought respectability to India's otherwise poor show. His younger colleagues continue to flunk tests of their techniques. And it's invariably the short ball that gets them curling up in foetal position.

So, while Dravid's comeback may suit India's short-term interests, it rankles on two counts.

One — in all probability, Dravid will be dumped again once India return home to their flat wickets. He was recalled in 2009 when our selectors saw that our flat-wicket bullies couldn't cope with the bouncy tracks for the Champions Trophy in South Africa.

What did Dravid do? He made 14, 47, 39, 76 and 4 — performances that don't warrant being dropped for two years. Just as he didn't warrant being dropped after one really bad series in 2007 when the rallying cry was Youth Power in the wake of the World T20 triumph. This use-and-throw policy may be justified for lesser players, not for one of the greatest batsmen in history.

Two — this side won the World Cup only four months back, and they didn't win it by looking backwards. Young players had a huge hand in this triumph, as did the policy to persist with them. So why recall a semi-retired player to bat for them now?

The saddest part of this retrograde step is that it will end badly for Dravid. He deserves better in the evening of his tremendous career.

Here's former selector Dilip Vengsarkar's reaction to Dravid's recall:

I’m worried about the reason and the thought process behind the recall. If Rahul is back because he plays the short balls well, it is a matter of great concern for Indian cricket. It means the youngsters cannot play the short balls.

This decision means the cupboard is empty. If the youngsters are not technically equipped to play the short ball, then they should be sent to the National Cricket Academy. But I have my doubts.

The catch? Vengsarkar said this in 2009. Two years later, despite a World Cup win, the reasoning and thought process continue to worry.

Some reactions on Twitter

@vikrantgupta73 - Now that Rahul Dravid has an "ODI Farewell" series, hope for VVS too. And why not get @souravganguly87 also to play a series or two. Joke

@bhogleharsha - so does dravid get to play on a flat deck at rajkot? i greatly fear that the selectors of the world champion team are panicking.

@cricketwallah - Dravid's a personal favourite and has been brilliant on this tour, but choosing him for ODIs shows confusion, not to mention a little panic

@cricketaakash - While I think that Dravid's absence from ODI was premature, going back to him as a stop-gap arrangement is adding insult to injury!

  • cricket
    Reuters

    Sports Direct shareholders veto payment to brother of founder Mike Ashley

    Sports Direct said last month a report by law firm RPC had found that John Ashley was entitled to the money for his work since the British retailer floated in 2007. It asked independent shareholders to vote on the matter.

  • cricket
    Reuters

    Australian soccer federation silent on Scolari claims

    Australia's soccer federation on Wednesday refused to comment on World Cup winning coach Luiz Felipe Scolari's claims that they had approached him about leading the Socceroos to the 2018 tournament in Russia. Scolari told Reuters that the Australians had spoken with his agent about him replacing Ange Postecoglou. Scolari told Reuters he would be happy to discuss a role with the Australians, but would want it to be long term, not only for the 2018 tournament in June and July.

  • cricket
    Reuters

    Gayle breaks sixes record in Bangladesh Premier League final

    Gayle, who was dropped by Shakib Al Hasan on 22, broke the record he set when he smashed 17 sixes in an unbeaten 175 for Royal Challengers Bangalore against Pune Warriors in the Indian Premier League's 2013 final. The 38-year-old Jamaican's knock also took him past 11,000 runs in the shortest format of the game and made him the first player to score 20 centuries in T20 cricket.

  • cricket
    Reuters

    Palace produce grandstand finish to beat Watford

    (Reuters) - CRYSTAL PALACE 2 WATFORD 1

  • cricket
    ANI

    Cannot make more mitsakes: Alastair Cook tellls England cricket team

    London [UK], Dec 13 (ANI): Alastair Cook has warned his teammates they "can't afford any more mistakes" as they seek to rebuild their connection with the general public in the aftermath of the incident involving Ben Stokes, reports the Mirror. Cook said, "The world's obviously changed for the England cricket team in September. It's sad in one sense because, a bit different to football, we've always been able to go under the radar a bit and enjoy playing cricket for England and also enjoy seeing the country outside of that." He further stated, "It's sad in some ways because we have always been a bit different to football and been able to go under the radar a bit and enjoy playing cricket for England and enjoy seeing the country outside that." The opening batsman also noted that the players need to adjust real soon as we cannot afford any more mistakes.

  • cricket
    AFP

    'Unique' Wagner an artist at work, says New Zealand coach

    Hamilton, New Zealand, Dec 12, 2017 (AFP) - New Zealand coach Mike Hesson heaped special praise Wednesday on Neil Wagner, whose bouncing barrage wreaked havoc in the West Indies ranks to set up a Test series sweep.

  • cricket
    AFP

    'Fed up' Root urges damaged England to stand up in crucial Test

    Perth, Australia, Dec 13, 2017 (AFP) - Captain Joe Root has challenged his England team to stand up and keep the Ashes series alive in Thursday's crucial third Test against Australia in Perth.

  • cricket
    ANI

    Hales to return to action in Ten10 League

    London [U.K], Dec 13 (ANI): England opener Alex Hales, who has been cleared of any wrongdoing in the Bristol incident, is all set to return to action with this week's inaugural Ten10 League in the UAE. The 28-year-old had been present in Bristol Mbargo's nightclub, where team vice-captain Ben Stokes was arrested after a wild street brawl, which allegedly inflicted bodily harm on a man. The pair was suspended indefinitely by the England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) pending the outcome of a police investigation into the matter.

  • cricket
    Reuters

    Motor racing: Concerned Formula One drivers put on united front

    Formula One drivers, including Britain's four times world champion Lewis Hamilton, have shown rare unanimity by all signing up for their union amid concern for the sport's future direction. Grand Prix Drivers' Association (GPDA) chairman Alex Wurz told the BBC on Wednesday that the Monaco-based organisation now had 100 percent membership "for maybe the first time in history". Hamilton, who clinched his fourth title with Mercedes this year, has not been a member in recent seasons while others who had been outside the body had included Ferrari's 2007 champion Kimi Raikkonen.

  • cricket
    ANI

    PCB raises objection to BCCI's FTP structure for 2019-23

    Lahore [Pakistan], Dec 13 (ANI): The Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) has quizzed the Board of Control for Cricket in India's (BCCI) proposed new Future Tours Programme for the 2019-2023 cycle, which does not feature the bilateral series between the two sides. During the BCCI's Special General Meeting (SGM) held in New Delhi on Monday, the board had maintained that the bilateral series between India and Pakistan will be possible only if the Centre gives the nod. "If the government agrees, we will make space for India-Pakistan bilateral series," BCCI acting secretary Amitabh Chaudhary had said following the SGM.

  • cricket
    Reuters

    Nigeria docked points, World Cup qualification unaffected

    Nigeria have been docked two points for fielding an ineligible player in a World Cup qualifier against Algeria but their place at next year's finals in Russia has not been affected, FIFA said on Tuesday. Nigeria, who had already qualified for the finals, drew 1-1 but FIFA awarded the match to Algeria by a 3-0 scoreline after the Super Eagles fielded the ineligible Abdullahi Shehu who had failed to serve a one-match ban for accumulated yellow cards.

  • cricket
    Reuters

    Zidane delighted to call on "world's best" Ronaldo

    Real Madrid coach Zinedine Zidane said he was delighted to be able to call on the "best player in the world" in Cristiano Ronaldo as his side gear up to defend their Club World Cup title. Ronaldo won his fifth Ballon d'Or, for world player of the year, last week to draw level with his rival and Barcelona forward Lionel Messi. The debate about who is the greater player is a perennial feature of soccer punditry, but Zidane is convinced he has the world's best at his disposal.

  • cricket
    Reuters

    Soccer: Halilhodzic urges China to trust 'best coach' Lippi

    Japan coach Vahid Halilhodzic has backed World Cup-winning manager Marcello Lippi to transform China into a team capable of qualifying for the 2022 finals in Qatar. Halilhodzic's side handed an inexperienced China side a 2-1 defeat in the second round of matches in this year's East Asian Championship on Tuesday to leave Lippi's side with no hope of claiming the regional title for a third time. "He's preparing for 2022 and all the players trust Lippi a lot," the former Algeria coach told reporters.

  • cricket
    Reuters

    Soccer: Germany sets World Cup victory bonus at 350,000 euros per player

    German players will receive 350,000 euros ($411,000) each if they successfully defend their World Cup title in Russia next year, the country's football association (DFB) said on Wednesday. When Germany won the title at the Brazil World Cup in 2014, players received a bonus of 300,000 euros each. The team under coach Joachim Loew will receive no payout for group stage victories or for reaching the round of 16, but a spot in the quarter-finals will earn each of them 75,000 euros and a semi-final place 125,000 euros.

  • cricket
    Reuters

    Barnes winner blasts Burnley up to fourth

    Burnley's Ashley Barnes fired a last-gasp winner as his off-colour side climbed to the heady heights of fourth in the Premier League with a fortuitous 1-0 win over struggling Stoke City on Tuesday. There was little to warm the home crowd on a wet and windy night but those who braved the wintry weather were celebrating in the 89th minute as Barnes seized on a ricochet off team mate Scott Arfield and thumped a shot past Stoke goalkeeper Jack Butland.