Isn’t a record of four wins out of five matches impressive? Not really, when two of those wins were a shaky performance against Afghanistan and an inconsequential league game against England. Not being able to finish in the top two in a four-team group will be counted as India's failure.
The inability to qualify for the World Twenty20 semifinals has put a question mark on the effectiveness of MS Dhoni and Duncan Fletcher. Since the two got together, success away from home has eluded the team. Their only claim to fame can be the West Indies Test series win in 2011.
Since then, India were routed in England and Australia, failed to make the finals of the one-day Tri-series in Australia and the Asia Cup in Dhaka. The debacle here has added insult to injury. The two are regarded among the shrewdest brains in cricket but have failed to click.
Dhoni is a pale shadow of what he was during his partnership with Gary Kirsten, and the T20 event in Sri Lanka is the latest example. In a format where one mistake can cost you the game, India failed to find a settled combination right till their exit.
For all the experiments by Dhoni and Fletcher, they could not get the team balance right. They remained in a dilemma over whether to pick a six batsmen-five bowler combination or play seven batsmen and four bowlers, and whether to play three pacers or an extra spinner.
Once the England batsmen floundered against spin, India fielded the same combination of five bowlers against Australia. It didn't reflect well on the tactical acumen of the captain and the coach. The strategy seemed to be based more on the hope that ‘what worked against England will work against Australia’.
One wondered if they took into account the fact that Shane Watson, David Warner and Mike Hussey were adept at playing spin on slow wickets due to their Indian Premier League stints.
There are bowling units for whom the opponents and conditions may not matter, but rating the Indian attack among them is wishful thinking, and thus the key lies in selecting horses for courses.
Dropping Virender Sehwag for Piyush Chawla was loaded with risk and it was the Australia game in the final analysis that sounded the death knell for India. They came back to win their next two Super Eights games but could not recover the ground conceded against Watson and Warner. The only time India looked to have got the combination right was against Pakistan and it reflected in the result.
If one thought wiser sense had finally prevailed, against South Africa the captain went in with an unchanged line-up. The three-pacer theory has often worked against Pakistan but it was surprising to see Dhoni use the combination against the Proteas.
And that too on a wicket where, minutes earlier, Pakistan had strangled Australia with spinners, not bowling their pacer till the 18th over.
In the end, despite the four wins, it was a shoddy performance, the prime example being the win over Afghanistan.
It was a torturous batting show with the batsmen edgy and nervous. They were only made to look good because of the poor catching by the inexperienced Afghans.
Dhoni at least has the cushion of his previous record, but for Fletcher, the signs are not good. The duo needs to get its, and the team's, act together, and fast.
When the captain and coach got it all wrong
For all the experiments by Dhoni and Fletcher, they could not get the team balance right.By Sanjjeev K Samyal, Hindustan Times | Yahoo! Cricket – Thu 4 Oct, 2012 10:47 AM IST
- ENG won by 170 runsvs. NZENG1st TestThu, May 16, 2013London, EnglandNew Zealand in England Tes...
- HYD won by 5 wkts.vs. KOLHYDMatch 72Sun, May 19, 2013Hyderabad, IndiaIndian Premier League, 201...
- vs. PAKSCO2nd ODIMatch abandonedSun, May 19, 2013Raeburn Place, Edinburgh, ScotlandPakistan in Scotland ODI S...
- live match CHE 52/0 (7 Overs)vs. MUMCHEQualifier 1LIVECurrent Run Rate 7.42Delhi, IndiaIndian Premier League, 201...
MORE TOP STORIES TODAY
Qualifier 1: MS Dhoni opts to bat against Mumbai at Kotla. More » Scorecard: Chennai vs Mumbai
[SPOT-FIXING ROUND-UP] Actor Vindoo Dara Singh arrested. More » SPOT-FIXING: Cops to grill Sreesanth for five more days
New Delhi, May 21 (IANS) Pune Warriors India, owned by Sahara India Pariwar, pulled out of the already scandal-hit Indian Premier League (IPL) Tuesday and announced that they will not renew their sponsorship … More » Sahara pulls out of IPL, not to renew BCCI sponsorship
He might be a bad boy, but he wasn’t a bad bowler. More » A character who was let down by his character
When the two face each other in Qualifier 1 of the Indian T20 league on Tuesday, with a spot in the final the reward for the winner, the rivalry will demand a lot more than usual. More » More than just spot in the final for these T20 titans
Corruption in cricket is as old as the apathy of the sport's administrators. More » [VOX] Crime and lack of punishment
Mumbai Indians skipper Rohit Sharma doesn't want his team to get distracted by the spot-fixing controversy in the Indian Premier League. More » Focus is on playing good cricket: Rohit
"The feeling is quite similar as no one gave the SunRisers a chance in the tournament, and we have qualified for the playoffs" More » 'Hyderabad's success reminds me of 1983'
It seems Rajasthan Royals, caught in the middle of the spot-fixing scandal involving three of their players, want to stay away from the spotlight as much as possible. More » Rajasthan feel heat ahead of playoff
LONDON, May 21, 2013 (AFP) - England on Tuesday named an unchanged squad for the second Test against New Zealand at Headlingley, after batsman Ian Bell and spin bowler Graeme Swann both overcame illne … More » Bell, Swann fit for second NZ Test
Cricket Australia said Tuesday it had no immediate plan to curb the use of social media by players after a Twitter rant by David Warner, but suggested it could happen in the future. More » Australia don't plan on Twitter clampdown
Chennai Super Kings coach Stephen Fleming said it was disappointing that spot fixing has overshadowed the IPL but hoped that the tournament would finish on a winning note. More » 'Corruption shadow over IPL's good work'
SG Test balls may be used for Ranji Trophy and junior tournaments. More » Kumble moots neutral venues, SG balls
"The contracts of all three players have been suspended pending enquiry," a team statement said. "We have already filed a complaint with the Delhi Police against all three players." More » Rajasthan suspend tainted players
Sensational revelations may be fine but the police needs solid evidence to prove the charges against ricketers arrested for spot-fixing to secure their conviction in court. More » Delhi cops face challenge in building case
Sreesanth had plans to party all night “with as many women as possible” on May 15, the Delhi Police have said. More » Revealed: Sreesanth's wild party side
Bookies have relied on 'gullible' players who've failed to make it big. More » 'Disillusioned' players on Police radar
Former New Zealand captain Daniel Vettori could play his first test for 10 months after spinner Bruce Martin was ruled out of the rest of the tour of England with a calf injury. More » Vettori replaces Martin in Test squad
"Warner is alleged to have breached Rule 6: Unbecoming Behaviour, regarding comments posted on his Twitter account," CA said in a statement. More » Hearing set for Warner over Twitter rant
James Anderson showed why it is so important for the hosts he remains fit for the Ashes with a first innings haul at Lord's of five for 47. More » Anderson confirms spearhead status
The NZ captain has faith in his batsmen after an "hour of madness" cost the team dear at Lord's. More » McCullum backs New Zealand batsmen
Hyderabad enter the play-offs on the back of a nervous five-wicket win over Kolkata. More » Sunrisers draw the blinds on RCB
Warriors avoid last-place finish with big win in last game. More » Pune banish Delhi to the bottom
Stuart Broad bowled England to victory in the first Test as New Zealand suffered a dramatic fourth-day collapse at Lord's on Sunday. More » Broad leads England rout of NZ
One of the rooms was used by Sreesanth and the second one was used by his friend Jiju Janardhanan More » Both rooms booked by Sreesanth
[ROUND-UP] Srinivasan refuses to blame the IPL; Shukla promises strong punishments. More » Cash, laptop seized from Sreesanth's room
Australia opening batsman David Warner will face a disciplinary hearing for his Twitter outburst against two senior Australian cricket journalists. More » Warner to face disciplinary hearing
Rajasthan Royals will file a police complaint against its three players arrested for spot fixing while the BCCI set up a panel to probe the scandal, board president N. Srinivasan announced. More » Rajasthan to slap charges against players, BCCI sets up probe panel
England captain Alastair Cook was satisfied with his team's performance after they beat New Zealand by 170 runs in a fluctuating first test at Lord's on Sunday. More » Cook happy with Eng's performance
Spot-fixing Scandal: No decision on life ban yet, Royals to file case against tainted trio More » Srinivasan: We can’t control bookies