As India’s tour of Australia meandered deeper into disaster, the team’s head coach Duncan Fletcher became the subject of jokes in the social media. “There’s no difference between the Indian cricket team’s coach and the country’s Prime Minister,” said one. “Duncan Fletcher is the new Manmohan Singh”, said another. The barbs were aimed at India’s disastrous run in international cricket under Fletcher’s charge. Those jokes, in all honesty, can’t be laughed as his first season in charge of the team has been underscored by a clear lack of vision and little or no reaction to arrest the slide that began at Lord’s during the English summer.
The first question-mark you raise against Fletcher’s stint is one of vision and fresh ideas, which unfortunately are completely lacking. There’s a hangover of the prosperous Gary Kirsten era which Fletcher has been unable to come to terms with. His approach has virtually tended to remain the same: erring on the side of caution, and not wanting to rock the boat, or perhaps — and I might be speculating here — being disallowed to do so by his employers.
You can cite a parallel from Premier League football. The Indian team’s situation at present is similar to Chelsea, whose owners resist change. As with the successful Kirsten era, Chelsea are hung-over from the Jose Mourinho era. Several coaches have come and gone since Mourinho; little has changed.
Sadly, by Fletcher’s own admission after the Sydney debacle earlier this year, nothing much has changed. “I don’t think much has changed. I had long chats with Gary. I am friendly with him. The approach, how you deal with an Indian side, we haven’t changed that much,” Fletcher said. The question still remains: what novelty is Fletcher bringing to the table that his predecessors haven’t already? This, to those who have read his autobiography, Behind the Shades, is very un-Fletcher like.
India’s 0-8 hammering in England and Australia has been painful to watch. Not least India’s mediocre batting but the sheer inability of every department to overcome their own errors has been a disappointment. It’s ironic that Fletcher — a firm batting coach — has been unable to influence some of the established players about their woeful technical shortcomings in foreign conditions. This was best exemplified in Australia by Rahul Dravid’s string of bowled dismissals and Gautam Gambhir’s falling-over and tentative footwork.
Is he hesitant in tapping these all-time greats on their shoulders and pointing out their weaknesses? This is where that strange sense of passivity you associate with Fletcher comes in. It’s not apathy. But it could be termed perceived detachment or the “let it be” approach. While that worked beautifully during Kirsten’s time, it has gone awry under Fletcher. However, the perception outside is that some of the Indian batsmen haven’t quite “learnt to use Fletcher’s services effectively”. Someone close to Fletcher pointed out that England’s batsmen still keep in touch with him, and regard his tips “invaluable.”
Tactically, barring small exceptions, Fletcher’s era has bordered on the same old. It has had nothing new that manifests Duncan Fletcher’s “theories”. Fletcher has a well-known fetish for express fast bowlers. Evidence suggests it has worked for him — right from his Glamorgan days where he brought Waqar Younis to the club, to his stint with England where his four-pronged pace attack had the likes of Simon Jones and Steve Harmison acing the 85 mph barrier often.
Fair enough, you’d say, and that’s where it’s a case of credit due — a theory that is supremely responsible for the gradual emergence of high pace in the Indian bowling narrative. The quiet rise of Umesh Yadav is something to look forward to. Even the mere identification of Varun Aaron as a future pace-bowling prospect (albeit via a cranky speedometer) is a decently healthy sign. The concern, however, is something else.
In an ideal world, you find pacers with discipline. But often, one must compromise control for pace. While Umesh has clocked over 150 kmph in Australia, it’s his inability to land six balls on a spot, the dirty habit of four bad balls in an over and critically, an inability make the batsman play at each of them that poses a problem. And the worthy challenge from here on, would involve taming Yadav into an effective pace bowler.
Even for a spinner, if you go by Fletcher’s numerous theories (not least the “cricket is a game of angles” one), Ravichandran Ashwin bowling his off-breaks from round the wicket, middle and leg line to a right-hander is considered an attacking angle, to which recent results have shown the contrary. Sadly, apart from changing the dimension of the bowling attack from the line-and-length stuff to bowling quick, Fletcher’s tactical contribution has been negligible. If anything, tactics bring the stubborn theorist in Fletcher out. In other words, if Plan A doesn’t work, keep trying Plan A till it works.
By his own admission, and full marks to that, Fletcher reckons India haven’t quite found the middle road yet — terrible inconsistency or too good at home, and nothing short of pathetic, away. Given that India play most of their Tests at home over the next 18 months or so, and since tactics and theories play little part in home conditions, where India have been unfailingly brilliant (even under Fletcher), he might have little to think over, modify or implement. But therein lies the wonderful opportunity for Fletcher to discover himself again and make that transformation from a theorist to a quiet reformist (something he’s still regarded highly for in English cricket circles) and ensure India’s cricketing destiny for the next five years, at least.
***Fletcher has to oversee the phasing out of senior players and the arrival of young ones.
What next for Fletcher, you ask? With India being out of international action for the next three months at the least, it could well mean a good healthy retreat back to Cape Town, back to his farms and dogs. Alternatively, he could well take the hard route of returning to his workplace, and use this break to primarily seek out his bosses and collectively introspect his tough year India have endured in international cricket. I’d hope for the latter, but I am guessing the former seems to be the more practical possibility. But either way, the space in India’s cricketing calendar provides ample time for Fletcher not just ponder over what might have been, but hopefully, consider what he could do next.
There’s almost a clarion, shrilling call for transition in India’s cricketing circles and one would imagine that Fletcher has this unenviable task of smoothly overseeing that process. And thankfully, Rahul Dravid has called it time and has rightly decided to move on. Also coinciding with Dravid’s departure from the Indian setup is the expeditious emergence of Virat Kohli, whose performances in the last 20 months or so has been nothing short of exceptional. Next in line could well be VVS Laxman, and if and when he takes the rather easy decision, India will have to bite the bullet and get going with his successor’s replacement.
Yes, as far as batting talents go, there’s an awful lot of back-up coming through the system, with and without international experience. Ajinkya Rahane, Cheteshwar Pujara and Rohit Sharma’s names will be thrown around on a regular basis and whoever gets the nod will almost instantly have to perform and consistently so. This not just presents Fletcher with an interesting challenge, but also, puts him in familiar territory.
In 2005, when Graham Thorpe exited English cricket ahead of the first Ashes Test at Lords, Fletcher called for Kevin Pietersen to be picked ahead of Ian Bell because he insisted on a No. 5 who could not just consolidate strong positions, but dominate bowling attacks with a degree of aggression. Rohit and Pujara, both though not in the same league as KP, should be credible frontrunners for that No. 5 position going by Fletcher’s “theory”. If anything, the fact that India play most of their cricket at home over the next 18 months should facilitate for the smooth transition by itself, especially given this belief that India should blood their youngsters at home before they’re exposed abroad.
One of the fundamental disappointments of the Fletcher era thus far, perhaps owing to tight schedules is the lack of interaction with the grassroot cricketing system within the country. A specific incident comes to mind. When India returned from England, Fletcher went home, skipping the Irani Trophy, where the Rest of India teams of yore were trained by national head coaches. But, this could yet change, given India’s home-heavy schedules in the next 18 months or so.
This would mean visiting specific domestic matches involving fringe players, giving the coaching staff additional opportunities to scout for specific aspects of the game in a match situation. It would also involve working closely with the National Cricket Academy, India’s U-19 and developmental squads. During this time, India’s ‘A’ team will be revived after a gap of two years and embark on a tour to the West Indies. Ideally, the BCCI must send Fletcher with the team not as coach but an observer, a scout to get a closer view of India’s bench strength and assess some of his wards.
The more interesting challenge comes with the bowling department, where Joe Dawes’ appointment couldn’t have been timed better. Both Dawes and Fletcher would at the least be required to assemble a bowling unit (not an attack) which would comprise of 10-15 bowlers at the bare minimum. This should involve what Fletcher himself calls an “intense” and “investigative” process of selection, keeping in touch with the line of thinking he seeks to promote i.e. pace. Interestingly, that is where Dawes’ temperate influence comes in, especially as someone who’s helped mentor some of the best young quicks in Queensland and South Australia. Talking of transition, it’s also time India start identifying an able replacement for Zaheer Khan, who at 33, doesn’t have a long international career ahead.
The next year or so will seek to define what the Fletcher era is going to really be about. For one, it’s a fairly exciting time to be an Indian coach, as unpopular as it may sound, given the results. This is because it’s got to a stage where certain things you’ve tried haven’t worked. This could well be time the time Fletcher starts demonstrating a certain degree of flexibility in his thinking, gradually ditching some of those three-decade old theories, and shelve that stubbornness, which surely doesn’t quite work in India and in a quiet little way rediscover himself as a coach. If ever Fletcher needed a good time to sit down and chalk India’s cricketing roadmap for the next five years or so, it’s now. For that to happen though, the dogs and the farm must wait.
What would Fletcher do?
India have suffered heavy defeats under their new coach. But he has the chance to turn things around.By Venkat Ananth | Yahoo! Cricket – Sat 31 Mar, 2012 8:54 PM IST
- No live matches are in progress.
MORE TOP STORIES TODAY
[ROUND-UP] The CSK team owner was taken into custody after interrogation. More » Meiyappan arrested, CSK face termination
The other finalists, Chennai Super Kings, are in grave danger of a dishonourable exit. More » Who will Mumbai play in the final?
Camp Srinivasan lacks a moral compass and a sense of fairplay. It is time Srinivasan resigned from his his positions as an administrator in Indian cricket. More » Evidence that Meiyappan is the Chennai team owner
What I wonder now, amidst these ruins, is this: how do I watch a cricket match again? More » [COMMENTS:] Paradise Lost
Understanding the fragility of the world's top players and the human element of the game have been the cornerstone of Gary Kirsten's approach to coaching international cricket teams. The 45-year-old heads … More » Interview: It's all in the mind for South African Kirsten
MUMBAI, May 24, 2013 (AFP) - Police said Friday they were "investigating all the angles" in the Indian spot-fixing scandal but refused to confirm if they were targeting top Pakistani umpire Asad Rauf. More » Police refuse to confirm they are investigating Rauf
New Delhi, May 24 (IANS) Having pulled out its franchise Pune Warriors from the Indian Premier League (IPL), Sahara chief Subrata Roy fired another salvo saying he would immediately stop sponsoring the … More » Subrata Roy wants Srinivasan out
LEEDS, United Kingdom, May 24, 2013 (AFP) - Rain meant there was no play on the first day of the second and final Test between England and New Zealand at Headingley on Friday. More » Eng-NZ: Rain plays spoilsport on Day 1
PepsiCo didn't confirm or deny if it was considering invoking a clause to look at a possible exit from its title sponsorship. More » Spot fixing: Pepsi mulls pulling out of IPL
Three Chennai Super Kings players, one of them quite senior, were in touch with Vindoo Dara Singh during the ongoing T20 season. More » Three Chennai players 'linked' to probe
[SPOT-FIXING ROUND-UP]: Meiyappan finally surfaces | Rauf dropped from ICC event More » Rauf dropped from Champions Trophy
Pakistan could manage only a tie in the first ODI against Ireland at a bitterly cold Clontarf after Kevin O'Brien hit the last ball of the match for four. More » Kevin gives Ireland thrilling tie with Pak
Rajasthan Royals skipper Rahul Dravid said dealing with the spot-fixing allegations surrounding his team in the IPL has been one of the toughest phases of his career. More » 'Dealing with spot-fixing has been tough'
Australian Test batsman David Warner has said that the Indian players caught in the IPL spot-fixing scandal should be banned from cricket. More » Warner calls for ban on IPL spot-fixers
Misbah ul-Haq has told his Pakistan team they must improve in all three departments ahead of Sunday's series decider with Ireland. More » All-round improvement needed: Misbah
Akhtar said that he doesn’t understand why Pakistani officials — umpires and coaching staff — are welcome in IPL while players have been kept out. More » Akhtar appalled by double standards
Cook believes Headingley will be far from the bowling-friendly ground of old when the second Test against New Zealand starts at Yorkshire's headquarters on Friday. More » Cook expects hard work at Headingley
Sunrisers Hyderabad came up short against Rajasthan Royals in the Eliminator here but their inaugural Indian Premier League campaign was a successful one, their captain Cameron White has said. More » 'Sunrisers can be proud of their effort'
Thanks to the format of the IPL, Mumbai Indians still have a chance to qualify for the final. More » Mumbai look to make most of second chance
Rajasthan Royals skipper Rahul Dravid hinted at retiring from the Indian Premier League (IPL) after this season. More » Dravid to hang up gloves for good?
He was ruled out after doubts over his ability to last a five-day match. More » Vettori out of second Test against England
Arrested Rajasthan Royals player Ajit Chandila had received Rs.12 lakh for spot fixing in IPL 2012 matches, Delhi Police said Thursday. More » Chandila spot fixed in 2012 IPL: Police
England captain Alastair Cook found himself being quizzed about the star batsman in Leeds on the eve of the second Test against New Zealand at Headingley. More » Absent KP puts pressure on England
Delhi Police contacted their counterparts in Mumbai seeking details about the articles seized from the hotel where Sreesanth stayed, said a police official. More » Delhi Police seek details of seizures
Result: embarrassment in one dressing room, and one set of flabbergasted bookies. More » A T20 match both teams wanted to lose
He facilitated others in Bollywood in placing bets with bookies he knew. More » Vindoo spills the beans on Bollywood
Royals will meet Mumbai Indian in the second qualifier. More » Hodge blinder floors Sunrisers
On the eve of the last edition of the Champions Trophy, set to begin within a week in England, Indian cricket is again mired in the fixing controversy. More » Will 'Champions' win back the fans?
Decision will save the Sahara Group a lot of money. More » Pune withdrawal a smart business move
Sachin Tendulkar will not take further part in the Indian Premier League owing to an injury on his left hand, his team Mumbai Indians said Wednesday. More » Tendulkar out of IPL with hand injury
David Warner regretted not keeping a lid on his outrage but maintained he had to defend himself after his image was used in a report condemning the IPL. More » Warner defends self for Twitter rant
Sports minister Jitendra Singh, however, wants that there should be certain minimum level of transparency and accountability that federations like the Indian cricket board need to ensure. More » Government wants BCCI to be transparent
Was Sreesanth planning to start betting houses in India and abroad? More » Revealed: Sreesanth's betting company
The BCCI blamed Sahara Adventure Sports Limited for the failure of the arbitration and said it "cannot be held responsible" for the breakdown of the process. More » Sahara to blame for arbitration failure
New Zealand's Daniel Vettori is on the verge of making a dramatic return to Test cricket as the Black Caps bid for a series-levelling win against England at Headingley. More » Vettori set for dramatic Test recall
England will look to seal a series win over New Zealand in the second and final test starting at Headingley on Friday before turning their attention to Australia in July. More » England eye NZ Test series win
Usman Khawaja says he is desperate to emerge from the periphery and consolidate a regular spot in the Australian team for this year's Ashes series against England. More » Khawaja looks to nail down Test spot
Coach Stephen Fleming credited his Chennai Super Kings' success to correct team selection and the loyalty the franchise has shown to the players. More » 'Selection key to Chennai's success'
It is his role in keeping some dubious cricketers suspected of match fixing outside the team. More » The feat Sachin never got praise for
New Zealand's Neil Wagner said Wednesday he wanted to make England's batsmen "hate him" and "get in their face" as the Black Caps look to square the Test series with victory at Headingley. More » Wagner wants England to 'hate him'
Joe Root said England would look to carry on from where they left off against New Zealand at Lord's during the second Test at his Headingley home ground. More » 'England can build on Lord's success'
Australian batsman David Warner was Wednesday found guilty of breaching Cricket Australia's code of behaviour over a Twitter tirade at two journalists and fined Aus$5,750 (US$5,608). More » David Warner fined for Twitter outburst
Chennai defeat Mumbai by 48 runs in the first Qualifier at Kotla. More » Kings boss their way to fifth IPL final
LEEDS, United Kingdom, May 22, 2013 (AFP) - New Zealand wicketkeeper BJ Watling was ruled out Wednesday of the second and final Test against England at Headingley starting Friday. More » New Zealand's Watling out of second Test
COLOMBO (Reuters) - Sri Lanka left-arm fast bowler Chanaka Welegedara has been ruled out of the Champions Trophy starting in England and Wales next month with an ankle injury. Welegedara will be replaced … More » Welegedara out of Champions Trophy
By Nick Mulvenney SYDNEY (Reuters) - Australia are rightly underdogs for the upcoming Ashes series in England but will do everything they can to bring the coveted urn back home, skipper Michael Clarke … More » Underdogs ready for Ashes scrap: Clarke
New Delhi, May 21 (IANS) Pune Warriors India, owned by Sahara India Pariwar, pulled out of the already scandal-hit Indian Premier League (IPL) Tuesday and announced that they will not renew their sponsorship … More » Sahara pulls out of IPL
India's apex court asks the Board to clean up the gentleman's game. More » Supreme Court raps 'lackadaisical' BCCI
One of the SunRisers' key bowlers, Ishant was nowhere to be seen and team officials said he was still down with fever. More » Ishant doubtful for win-or-go home clash
Starting off as the team's first-choice wicketkeeper, a string of poor performances with the bat saw Patel being dropped. More » Parthiv glad to have peaked at right time