Senators grill Hagel over anti-Israel remarks

Washington, Feb. 1: Barack Obama may be the most powerful man on earth who won the battle for America's presidency twice, but barely two weeks into his second term Obama risks defeat from a foreign country that is not even one-eighth the size of Florida and their lobbyists in Washington.

Chuck Hagel, Obama's nominee to be America's 24th secretary of defence, was yesterday humiliated in a nearly eight-hour grilling on Capitol Hill when the world saw Hagel apologising for his remarks that were perceived as anti-Israel and the nominee grovelling for forgiveness for having said some home truths about the Jewish lobby here.

If the money and resources being poured into an orchestrated campaign to block Hagel's nomination does not split the 55 Democrats in the 100-member Senate, the former Republican Senator from Nebraska may yet win confirmation to head the Pentagon.

However, he will be sworn in as a much chastened man who will not forget for a long time the heavy price that American politicians have to pay if they dare to utter a word against Israel.

Senators who are nominated for cabinet posts normally sail through confirmation hearings with ease: John Kerry's appointment this week as secretary of state was little more than a formality with his colleagues heaping praise on him and grilling him was farthest from the mind of any senator.

But Hagel had committed the indiscretion of saying five years ago that "the Jewish lobby intimidates a lot of people" on Capitol Hill into taking actions on behalf of Israel and often contrary to America's interests. It is a statement that any American who is objective knows to be true, but most people also know that anyone saying it in public risks losing everything he values.

"I am sorry and I regret it," Hagel pleaded for forgiveness with members of the Senate Armed Services Committee that was considering his nomination yesterday. "On the use of 'intimidation', I should have used 'influence', I think would have been more appropriate."

On another occasion, Hagel chastised Israel for "keep(ing) Palestinians caged up like animals", which is also a charge that is not far from the truth. But yesterday he was forced to tell his former colleagues who had turned into inquisitors that "if I had an opportunity to edit that, like many things I have said, I would like to go back and change the words".

Republicans had other reasons to haul Hagel over the coals. He is an apostate among them, having opposed George W. Bush's 2006 "surge" in Iraq with additional troops and then argued in the Senate that it "represents the most dangerous foreign policy blunder in this country since Vietnam".

It is almost unheard of that a senator from a nominee's home state opposes a cabinet nominee who served as a senator from the same state. But yesterday, Deb Fischer, the new Republican senator from Hagel's own Nebraska, indicated that she would vote against the defence secretary-designate calling him "extreme" and "far to the Left" of Obama. Although Obama is not a Leftist by any yardstick, Republicans view him as one.

Seantor John McCain, who was defeated by Obama in the 2008 US presidential election was unsparing in his attack on Hagel for his stand against the Iraqi surge. Their exchange, which ignited the committee room went like this, in part:

McCain: Do you stand by that ' those comments, Senator Hagel?

Hagel: Well, Senator, I stand by them because I made them. McCain: You stand by ' were you right?

Hagel: Well

McCain: I want to know if you were right or wrong. That's a direct question. I expect a direct answer.

Hagel: The surge assisted in the objective. But if we review the record a little bit

McCain: Will you please answer the question? Were you correct or incorrect when you said that the surge would be the most dangerous foreign policy blunder in this country since Vietnam? Were you correct or incorrect?

Hagel: My

McCain: Yes or no?

Hagel: My reference to the surge being both dangerous

McCain: Are you going to answer the question, Senator Hagel? The question is, were you right or wrong? That's a pretty straightforward question.

Hagel: Well

It was an unusual exchange for its lack of cordiality because both McCain and Hagel are Vietnam war veterans, both recipients of "Purple Heart" decoration given to the wounded.

Republicans are opposing Hagel also for his views on Iran, which are not consistent with Tel Aviv's hawkish stand of which Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is an embodiment. "I think engagement is clearly in our interest," Hagel told the committee yesterday.

Republicans were outraged. One of them, Saxby Chambliss, immediately accused the nominee of wanting to negotiate with a "terrorist state".

Hagel responded that "engagement is not appeasement. Engagement is not surrender", but his inquisitors would not listen. So intense were their attacks on Hagel that at one point the former Senator was so unnerved into misrepresenting Obama's stand on Iran.

There is a convention in the Senate that the chamber normally lets the President have his way on cabinet appointments. But if the campaign against Hagel builds up and splits the Democrats, the Republicans may be emboldened to "filibuster" his nomination, for which they need 60 votes.

But they are not there yet and the conventional wisdom is that Hagel may be approved strictly on a vote on party lines.

Matches

MORE TOP STORIES TODAY

England, South Africa look to ride their luck

England, South Africa look to ride their luck

The teams square-off in the Champions Trophy semi-final at the Oval today. More »

Resurgent India impress Jayawardene

Resurgent India impress Jayawardene

Sri Lanka's Mahela Jayawardene is under no illusions about the scale of the task confronting his side when they face India in a Champions Trophy semi-… More »

Dalmiya or Srini, song remains the same on DRS

Dalmiya or Srini, song remains the same on DRS

After much speculation, the cricket board will decide on Thursday who will represent BCCI at International Cricket Council's annual conference from June… More »

The secret behind Dhoni's massive sixes

The secret behind Dhoni's massive sixes

Watching MS Dhoni hit sixes is a visual delight that touches a chord at a primeval level. It's instinctive, it's visceral. More »

Whatmore eyes World Cup after Pakistan flop

Whatmore eyes World Cup after Pakistan flop

The former Australian batsman turned coach rejected the suggestion his players lacked in effort. More »

Rare world title beckons England

Rare world title beckons England

Their only major title in cricket's shorter formats is the 2010 World Twenty20 they won in the Caribbean. More »

Cummins set for return to action

Cummins set for return to action

Rising Australia fast bowling hope Pat Cummins is to make an unusual return to action from injury by playing for the Northern Ireland Cricket Academy on… More »

Lankans ready for another tough match

Lankans ready for another tough match

Sri Lanka barged into the Champions Trophy semi-finals with a 20-run victory over holders Australia. More »

Hughes and Wade join Aus A side

Hughes and Wade join Aus A side

Australia said on Tuesday that captain Michael Clarke will stay in London as he recovers from a back problem. More »

I am 'happy to be alive': Harbhajan

I am 'happy to be alive': Harbhajan

Harbhajan Singh, who was amongst the many pilgrims and tourists stranded in the upper reaches of Uttarakhand due to the landslides and heavy rains, on… More »

Don't write off Aussies, says Inverarity

Don't write off Aussies, says Inverarity

Australia's chairman of selectors has told England now is not the time to dismiss his side's chances of regaining the Ashes, despite the controversy currently… More »

Bhuvneshwar Kumar: Swinging in the rain

Bhuvneshwar Kumar: Swinging in the rain

Cardiff, June 17 -- Swing bowling is a complex science and not an absolute one. The basics are simple enough.Swing occurs due to the uneven distribution… More »

[RUN MACHINES] Mahela passes Dravid on way to 11,000th run

The Sri Lankan became the eighth man to pass 11,000 runs in one-day internationals. More »

Inverarity: Fawad Ahmed is a lovely lad

Inverarity: Fawad Ahmed is a lovely lad

LONDON, June 17, 2013 (AFP) - John Inverarity, Australia's chairman of selectors, indicated Monday that Pakistan-born leg-spinner Fawad Ahmed could yet… More »

Hesson laments NZ's failure to grab chances

Hesson laments NZ's failure to grab chances

The New Zealand coach rued the Black Caps' exit from the Champions Trophy. More »

Chandila sent to 3-day police custody

Chandila sent to 3-day police custody

Police sought fresh custody of Chandila saying he was required to corroborate evidence collected from other accused after invoking the stringent MCOCA… More »

Abdullah objects to IMG faux pas

Abdullah objects to IMG faux pas

Senior Union Minister Farooq Abdullah on Monday strongly objected to a prominent sports management company unilaterally altering the map of Jammu and Kashmir… More »

The prodigal son

The prodigal son

If Sreesanth did what he is accused of, it is doubtful he realised he was doing something wrong. More »

Who'll watch the administrators?

Who'll watch the administrators?

It's rich to accuse players of being selfish when administrators seem concerned solely with the bottom line. More »

BCCI using fixing video to warn juniors

BCCI using fixing video to warn juniors

With spot-fixing under the scanner in India, the cricket Board is showing video clips of the scandal involving Aamer to educate its under-19 and under-25… More »

India retain squad for WI tri-series

India retain squad for WI tri-series

India's cricket selectors on Monday retained the Champions Trophy squad for a triangular one-day series in the West Indies starting later this month. More »

BCCI needs to accept DRS immediately

BCCI needs to accept DRS immediately

Cricket needs to eradicate human errors and technology is the only option. More »

Boycott still upset about run-out: Amiss

Boycott still upset about run-out: Amiss

Interview with the former England opening batsman, pioneer of batting helmets and scorer of 102 First Class hundreds. More »