India win, but Pakistan go through

SA lose by one run, yet Pakistan qualify for semifinals with a better run rate.

Scores | Action In Images | Results So Far | Fixtures | Full Coverage

Four wins out of five, yet India will go home.

Funny are the vagaries of cricket. It’s the second round of a World Cup and a team that lost today — Australia — is going to the semifinals. And the team that won later in the evening — India — is going home. It’s hard to think of another sport where such an oddity would occur at a World Cup.

But that’s the Super Eights format for you – an ICC invention that allows one team to get away with a bad day, and another team to pay for it through its nose; one that makes calculators more important than bats and balls. India won four games out of five in the tournament, the same as Australia, but one bad spell of 10-odd overs against Australia did them in.

Compare that to the West Indies: they are in the semifinals despite one win less than India, and only one outright win if you discount winning by a Super Over. This run-rate gobbledygook could have been avoided with the simple yet effective knockouts format which would have seen four meaningful quarterfinals instead of these run-rate-reliant Super Eights games which create convoluted contests like this one.

There was nothing to take from this game for South Africa. Thanks to Pakistan exposing Australia’s inadequacies earlier today, South Africa were out of the semifinals race. But India had half a chance of qualification. The men with the calculators informed us that MS Dhoni’s needed to win this game by scoring at least 150 and then winning by 32 runs or more.

Thanks to a top-order that has been all show, no go, India barely got over the 150-run mark with a fine counter-punching stand by Suresh Raina and MS Dhoni. But the magic number for Pakistan was a mere 122. When South Africa got over that mark with 20 balls to spare, they had ensured Pakistan a superior net run rate than India's. The large Pakistani contingent at the Premadasa Stadium today cheered South Africa’s march towards 122. One could call it Pakistan’s first cricketing win over India at a World Cup. So what if it was by proxy.

While the result itself had failed to matter afterwards, this game was a thriller in its own right. South Africa lost Hashim Amla and Jacques Kallis early, but Faf du Plessis’ 65 (38b) settled the qualification race. Now the attention turned towards South Africa trying to chase down the 153-run target for their first win of the Super Eights.

Wickets fell and the contest got tighter. It boiled down to 14 off the last over from Lakshmipathy Balaji. The Morkel brothers each clubbed a six over midwicket in that over and got out immediately after, letting Balaji be the hero of the one-run win.

INDIA SLOPPY WITH THE BAT

Yuvraj bowled better than he batted in the tournament. India’s opening combination has been persisted with like a compromise marriage. No surprises then that Gautam Gambhir and Virender Sehwag failed to get it on. Gambhir crossed 20 just once at the World Twenty20. Sehwag, despite the fuss over his exclusion in the Australia game and him sulking about it in practice, never crossed 30.

Gambhir played on to Morkel attempting a strange walking dab. Soon, Sehwag lifted Peterson down the ground for a big six, and then tried to repeat the shot. Peterson showed great courage, bowled the next ball slower and Sehwag missed it completely to be bowled. Watching Sehwag bat is at once one of life’s greatest pleasures and frustrations. He’ll thrill you by playing shots mere mortals can only dream of. Then he’ll disappoint by getting out like that making you wonder if he has the IQ of a potato.

Gambhir and Sehwag’s collective failures have burdened the middle order gripped by form issues of its own. While Kohli has been sublime at No. 3, Yuvraj has been far from his best at No. 4. He’s made a swift comeback after a life-threatening disease, but he didn’t thrill with the bat the way he had at the previous editions of the World Twenty20. One of the positives was his bowling: he had eight wickets in the tournament. Rohit Sharma had one big knock against England, but was a let-down in the other games. 

Each time they went to bat Dhoni and Raina had to try and compensate for the collective failures of their colleagues. In retrospect, it’s a wonder India won four games out of five in the tournament. India went into the WT20 banking on their batting. While the batting underwhelmed, the bowlers (India's perennial weakness) bowled out four of their five opponents. It wasn't enough. Perhaps, in another year at some other tournament, the men with the calculators will have favourable news for Dhoni.

Also Read

Matches

MORE TOP STORIES TODAY

Live: England vs South Africa

Live: England vs South Africa

Champions Trophy, Semi-Final: Proteas in tatters after put in to bat first. More »

[SPECIAL] Is history repeating itself?

[SPECIAL] Is history repeating itself?

[ODDBALL THEORIES] Startling similarities connect India’s twin ODI triumphs of 1983 and 1985 with their performances in the 2011 World Cup and 2013 Champions… More »

Pakistan court orders interim board chief

Pakistan court orders interim board chief

KARACHI, June 19, 2013 (AFP) - A Pakistani court Wednesday ordered the government to appoint an interim head of the cricket board, after the current chairman… More »

India vs Sri Lanka: The road to Champions Trophy semis

How India and Sri Lanka reached the last four to set up a repeat of the 2011 World Cup final.ALSO READ: Resurgent India impress Jayawardene More »

Resurgent India impress Jayawardene

Resurgent India impress Jayawardene

Sri Lanka's Mahela Jayawardene is under no illusions about the scale of the task confronting his side when they face India in a Champions Trophy semi-… More »

Dalmiya or Srini, song remains the same on DRS

Dalmiya or Srini, song remains the same on DRS

After much speculation, the cricket board will decide on Thursday who will represent BCCI at International Cricket Council's annual conference from June… More »

The secret behind Dhoni's massive sixes

The secret behind Dhoni's massive sixes

Watching MS Dhoni hit sixes is a visual delight that touches a chord at a primeval level. It's instinctive, it's visceral. More »

Ahmed, Sandhu in Australia A tour of Africa

Ahmed, Sandhu in Australia A tour of Africa

Pakistan-born leg-spinner Fawad Ahmed was Wednesday named on the Australia A squad for a tour of Africa beginning next month, despite also being in contention… More »

Lankans ready for another tough match

Lankans ready for another tough match

Sri Lanka barged into the Champions Trophy semi-finals with a 20-run victory over holders Australia. More »

Cummins set for return to action

Cummins set for return to action

Rising Australia fast bowling hope Pat Cummins is to make an unusual return to action from injury by playing for the Northern Ireland Cricket Academy on… More »

Hughes and Wade join Aus A side

Hughes and Wade join Aus A side

Australia said on Tuesday that captain Michael Clarke will stay in London as he recovers from a back problem. More »

Whatmore eyes WC after Pak flop

Whatmore eyes WC after Pak flop

The former Australian batsman turned coach rejected the suggestion his players lacked in effort. More »

Don't write off Aussies, says Inverarity

Don't write off Aussies, says Inverarity

Australia's chairman of selectors has told England now is not the time to dismiss his side's chances of regaining the Ashes, despite the controversy currently… More »

I am 'happy to be alive': Harbhajan

I am 'happy to be alive': Harbhajan

Harbhajan Singh, who was amongst the many pilgrims and tourists stranded in the upper reaches of Uttarakhand due to the landslides and heavy rains, on… More »

Bhuvneshwar Kumar: Swinging in the rain

Bhuvneshwar Kumar: Swinging in the rain

Cardiff, June 17 -- Swing bowling is a complex science and not an absolute one. The basics are simple enough.Swing occurs due to the uneven distribution… More »

[RUN MACHINES] Mahela passes Dravid on way to 11,000th run

The Sri Lankan became the eighth man to pass 11,000 runs in one-day internationals. More »

Inverarity: Fawad Ahmed is a lovely lad

Inverarity: Fawad Ahmed is a lovely lad

LONDON, June 17, 2013 (AFP) - John Inverarity, Australia's chairman of selectors, indicated Monday that Pakistan-born leg-spinner Fawad Ahmed could yet… More »

Hesson laments NZ's failure to grab chances

Hesson laments NZ's failure to grab chances

The New Zealand coach rued the Black Caps' exit from the Champions Trophy. More »

Chandila sent to 3-day police custody

Chandila sent to 3-day police custody

Police sought fresh custody of Chandila saying he was required to corroborate evidence collected from other accused after invoking the stringent MCOCA… More »

Abdullah objects to IMG faux pas

Abdullah objects to IMG faux pas

Senior Union Minister Farooq Abdullah on Monday strongly objected to a prominent sports management company unilaterally altering the map of Jammu and Kashmir… More »

The prodigal son

The prodigal son

If Sreesanth did what he is accused of, it is doubtful he realised he was doing something wrong. More »

Who'll watch the administrators?

Who'll watch the administrators?

It's rich to accuse players of being selfish when administrators seem concerned solely with the bottom line. More »

BCCI using fixing video to warn juniors

BCCI using fixing video to warn juniors

With spot-fixing under the scanner in India, the cricket Board is showing video clips of the scandal involving Aamer to educate its under-19 and under-25… More »

India retain squad for WI tri-series

India retain squad for WI tri-series

India's cricket selectors on Monday retained the Champions Trophy squad for a triangular one-day series in the West Indies starting later this month. More »