Charge of NGO funds racket

New Delhi, Jan. 18: A rights organisation today accused the Centre and state governments of giving huge, unaccounted grants to NGOs including blacklisted ones, often against a bribe.

The Asian Centre for Human Rights said it was basing its claims on replies to a series of RTI applications it had filed in 2010. Releasing the report, "India's Funds to NGOs Squandered", the rights body's director, Suhas Chakma, made these claims at a news conference here:

Between 2002-03 and 2008-09, the Centre released Rs 4,756 crore and the states Rs 1,897 crore in grants to NGOs ' a total of Rs 6,653 crore in seven years.

This isn't the full figure as many departments and PSUs withheld the information sought or understated the figures, going by government statements in Parliament.

The total funds given to NGOs that were blacklisted ' mainly for irregularities in past projects and expenditure ' cannot be ascertained because only two ministries' replies listed the recipients.

The lists show that the Council for the Advancement of People's Action and Rural Technology, an autonomous body under the Union rural development ministry, released Rs 46.8 lakh in 2009 to five NGOs it had blacklisted in 2007. The five are: Nirmala Weaker Section (Andhra), Sarvodaya Ashram (Bihar), Magadh Social Development Society (Bihar), Pazhakulam Social Service Society (Kerala) and Vijay Warangal Trust (Maharashtra).

The Union women and child development ministry continued to give Rs 110 crore annually to three NGOs it had banned in 2006. These are the Central Social Welfare Board, Indian Council of Child Welfare and the Bharatiya Adim Jati Sewak Sangh.

Contacted by The Telegraph, officials of these two ministries refused comment.

Chakma said Union government funds are given to NGOs only if they have a recommendation from a state government.

"This facilitates corruption. In most cases, only NGOs that are close to government officials or have control over political leaders are selected for grants. The selection is often based not on expertise but on the applicant's ability to pay a bribe," Chakma said.

He said many NGOs had told him the bribe ranged from 15 to 30 per cent of the grant.

"Using a conservative estimate of 15 per cent, at least Rs 1,000 crore was spent on bribes to different layers of officials between 2002-2003 and 2008-2009. That blacklisted NGOs are re-funded exposes the malaise," alleged Chakma, who said his organisation worked across South and Southeast Asia but did not seek or receive Indian government funds.

A former NGO official who didn't want to be named confirmed to this newspaper that "bribes" were very much part of the grants process.

Speaking to The Telegraph later, Chakma cited how the CAG had in April 2012 expressed dismay at the rising volume of funds disbursed by the ministries to local bodies and NGOs.

"A major concern repeatedly brought out by CAG is that accounts of funds utilised by the implementing agencies are not readily available and there is need to ascertain whether there are unspent funds lying with these agencies," the report said.

It added that "77 per cent of the total plan expenditure was in the form of grants-in-aid payment" and that "in five of the 10 ministries and departments incurring the largest plan expenditure, over 99 per cent was in the form of disbursement of grants-in-aid".

Chakma, whose organisation is part of the National Human Rights Commission's core group of NGOs, said: "All government programmes for socio-economic growth are now implemented through collaboration with the private sector and civil society. So how the government gives money to NGOs for delivery of service needs to be clear."

He added: "The government has been focusing on foreign funding but hasn't realised the amount it itself allocates to voluntary organisations without accountability."

Matches

MORE TOP STORIES TODAY

Live: India vs Sri Lanka at Cardiff

Live: India vs Sri Lanka at Cardiff

Champions Trophy, 2nd Semi-Final: Dilshan retires hurt, Indians on charge More »

Champions Trophy: One Final Time

As you wait for the final of the final edition of the Champions Trophy, take a look at what happened on the previous six occasions.  [TAG: CYCSPL… More »

Pietersen set for return to international cricket

Pietersen set for return to international cricket

England batsman Kevin Pietersen is poised for a return to international cricket in the second T20 match against New Zealand after a long lay-off with … More »

South Africa deserve chokers tag, admits Kirsten

South Africa deserve chokers tag, admits Kirsten

South Africa's coach Gary Kirsten admitted his team deserved the tag of chokers after it crashed to a seven-wicket defeat by England in the Champions Trophy… More »

Inspired England storm into Champions Trophy final

Inspired England storm into Champions Trophy final

Champions Trophy: Hosts thrash South Africa by seven wickets at The Oval. More »

[SPECIAL] Is history repeating itself?

[SPECIAL] Is history repeating itself?

Startling similarities connect India’s twin ODI triumphs of 1983 and 1985 with their performances in the 2011 World Cup and 2013 Champions Trophy. More »

Tendulkar to own badminton franchise?

Tendulkar to own badminton franchise?

A prominent cricketer, said to be Sachin Tendulkar, has bought the Mumbai franchise in the million-dollar Indian Badminton League. Hyderabad-based PVP… More »

CA rejects TV influence over team pick

CA rejects TV influence over team pick

Cricket Australia has dismissed suggestions from executives at Channel Nine that the network should have a say in team selection. More »

Oz citizenship and Ashes beckon Ahmed

Oz citizenship and Ashes beckon Ahmed

Pakistan-born leg-spinner Fawad Ahmed is on the brink of becoming an Australian citizen and being eligible to play in the Ashes. More »

Pakistan court orders interim board chief

Pakistan court orders interim board chief

A Pakistani court Wednesday ordered the government to appoint an interim head of the cricket board, after the current chairman was suspended over a legal… More »

BCCI song remains the same on DRS

BCCI song remains the same on DRS

After much speculation, the cricket board will decide on Thursday who will represent BCCI at International Cricket Council's annual conference from June… More »

Adamant Srini wants to attend ICC meeting

Adamant Srini wants to attend ICC meeting

Most senior BCCI functionaries want Srinivasan to stay away till the outcome of the internal probe against his son-in-law, M Gurunath, over his alleged… More »

Sri Lanka are a dangerous side, says Dhoni

Sri Lanka are a dangerous side, says Dhoni

India captain Mahendra Singh Dhoni said on Wednesday that Sri Lanka were a dangerous side and it was not possible to focus only on their two frontline… More »

The secret behind Dhoni's massive sixes

The secret behind Dhoni's massive sixes

Watching MS Dhoni hit sixes is a visual delight that touches a chord at a primeval level. It's instinctive, it's visceral. More »

Ahmed, Sandhu in Australia A tour of Africa

Ahmed, Sandhu in Australia A tour of Africa

Pakistan-born leg-spinner Fawad Ahmed was Wednesday named on the Australia A squad for a tour of Africa beginning next month, despite also being in contention… More »

Angelo Mathews has plans for India

Angelo Mathews has plans for India

Sri Lanka and India ready themselves for semifinal. More »

Resurgent India impress Jayawardene

Resurgent India impress Jayawardene

Sri Lanka's Mahela Jayawardene is under no illusions about the scale of the task confronting his side when they face India in a Champions Trophy semi-… More »

Lankans ready for another tough match

Lankans ready for another tough match

Sri Lanka barged into the Champions Trophy semi-finals with a 20-run victory over holders Australia. More »

Whatmore eyes WC after Pak flop

Whatmore eyes WC after Pak flop

The former Australian batsman turned coach rejected the suggestion his players lacked in effort. More »

Cummins set for return to action

Cummins set for return to action

Rising Australia fast bowling hope Pat Cummins is to make an unusual return to action from injury by playing for the Northern Ireland Cricket Academy on… More »

Hughes and Wade join Aus A side

Hughes and Wade join Aus A side

Australia said on Tuesday that captain Michael Clarke will stay in London as he recovers from a back problem. More »

Don't write off Aussies, says Inverarity

Don't write off Aussies, says Inverarity

Australia's chairman of selectors has told England now is not the time to dismiss his side's chances of regaining the Ashes, despite the controversy currently… More »

I am 'happy to be alive': Harbhajan

I am 'happy to be alive': Harbhajan

Harbhajan Singh, who was amongst the many pilgrims and tourists stranded in the upper reaches of Uttarakhand due to the landslides and heavy rains, on… More »

Bhuvneshwar Kumar: Swinging in the rain

Bhuvneshwar Kumar: Swinging in the rain

Cardiff, June 17 -- Swing bowling is a complex science and not an absolute one. The basics are simple enough.Swing occurs due to the uneven distribution… More »